WHEN METRICS REPLACE MANAGERS: ALGORITHMIC PERFORMANCE EVALUATION AND SUPERVISOR TRUST
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52152/d1pds138Abstract
The increasing use of algorithmic systems to monitor, quantify, and evaluate employee performance is changing the traditional relationship between employees and their immediate supervisors. Although prior research has investigated employee trust in algorithms and perceptions of algorithmic fairness, considerably less attention has been given to whether metric-driven performance evaluation changes trust in the human supervisor who remains responsible for communicating and implementing performance decisions. This study examines six direct predictors of supervisor trust in algorithmically managed performance environments: algorithmic performance evaluation reliance, perceived algorithmic fairness, evaluation transparency, perceived supervisor discretion, perceived evaluation accuracy, and employee voice. Reliability and validity assessments were conducted before the hypotheses were tested using multiple regression. The results indicate that algorithmic performance evaluation reliance is negatively associated with supervisor trust (β = −.177, p < .001), whereas perceived fairness (β = .210, p < .001), supervisor discretion (β = .245, p < .001), evaluation accuracy (β = .193, p < .001), and employee voice (β = .138, p = .004) are positively associated with trust. Transparency does not retain a statistically significant unique relationship after the other evaluation characteristics are considered (β = .077, p = .107). Collectively, the predictors explain 42.5% of the variance in supervisor trust. The study extends algorithmic-management research by shifting attention from trust in technology to trust in the human manager operating within algorithmically structured performance systems. The findings suggest that organizations should avoid reducing supervisors to passive transmitters of metric-based judgments and should preserve meaningful managerial discretion, fairness, accuracy, and opportunities for employee voice.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Lex localis - Journal of Local Self-Government

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.


